A package delivery dispute in a Richmond alley left one man injured and another facing two Level 3 felonies after police say Tyrell David, 28, pulled a knife during an altercation.
David was arrested and charged with criminal confinement while armed with a deadly weapon and aggravated battery posing a substantial risk of death, both Level 3 felonies, along with Level 5 counts of battery by means of a deadly weapon and intimidation where a defendant draws or uses a deadly weapon.
His bond was set at $22,500 with 10 percent cash authorized, and public records show he posted bail through the Wayne County Clerk’s Office.
The stabbing unfolded Nov. 17 in an alley between South 5th Street and South 6th Street, where officers found a victim with a three-or-four-inch laceration on his left side.
The injured man told police he had been trying to break up an argument or dispute of some kind when he was injured, adding that he did not know the person who stabbed him and had fled toward a bar afterward, hearing a loud boom as he ran.
Witnesses gave investigators a picture of what sparked the violence. David had gone to the house where the scuffle happened to retrieve a package for somebody else. The person who sent him to get the package used to live at the home, according to court documents.

With the knife in hand, David reportedly charged a person and stood over them. Some witnesses indicated that David tried to stab the person in the neck and chest multiple times. The victim got involved and tried to break up the fight.
Police located David near the intersection of Boston Township Line Road and State Road 227 South, where he had crashed his car. During an interview, he broke down in tears several times, said he was not an evil person, and expressed remorse for injuring someone uninvolved with the fight, the affidavit states.
David confirmed the fight happened when he went to pick up a package. He said someone damaged his taillight — first indicating it happened for no reason, then saying the person may have damaged his taillight because he called her a profane name.
He also told police that somebody flashed a gun at him multiple times during the dispute and said a shot was fired at him, prompting him to exit his car with the knife.
Investigators also pressed David on his rationale for remaining at the scene as the spat kept intensifying. At first, David’s response was because “he thought they were going to fight.” As officers followed up, he said he didn’t know why he stayed at the scene.
Wayne County, where Richmond serves as the county seat, was formed in 1811 and named for Revolutionary War officer Gen. “Mad” Anthony Wayne. The county’s early Quaker settlers established stations on the Underground Railroad, and Levi Coffin’s Fountain City home aided more than 1,000 refugees from slavery, a site now recognized as a National Historic Landmark. The county also holds Indiana’s highest natural point, Hoosier Hill, at 1,257 feet.
When officers presented a consent form to search his car for the knife, David requested an attorney. Detective T. Legear of the Richmond Police Department’s Investigative Services Division led the investigation.