Three nuclear-armed leaders stood shoulder-to-shoulder in Shenzhen on Wednesday, a tableau the White House once treated as unthinkable and Beijing staged as inevitable.
Donald Trump arrived in China on November 18 for a trilateral summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin that brought the world’s three largest nuclear arsenals to a single table, The Business Times reported.
The gathering unfolded at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in the southern tech hub, where Xi opened proceedings by calling for “free and open trade” — a direct jab at U.S. tariffs — while Putin used his remarks to assail Western sanctions over Ukraine.
President Donald J. Trump greets Chinese President Xi Jinping as he arrives at the APEC Summit in Shenzhen. pic.twitter.com/En2EK0FX7s
CNN analysis said that Russia and China are not America’s friends and questioned why Trump thinks they are.
The visual choreography was deliberate. At the welcome banquet, Putin raised a glass of red wine to join a toast led by Xi, seated just spots away from Trump, CNBC observed. The group photograph placed Xi flanked by the American and Russian presidents, a framing Chinese state media broadcast as the host convening the other two great powers.
Trump wants nuclear arms control on the agenda. Xi would rather avoid it.
Beijing is engaged in a massive build-up to reach parity with Washington and Moscow, and Chinese strategists have long viewed treaties as tools the strong use to constrain the weak — a mindset rooted in the 1963 Partial Test Ban Treaty, which Premier Zhou Enlai dismissed as “a huge swindle” because it permitted underground tests the established powers could still conduct, the Council on Foreign Relations noted.
Ukraine and Iran are also on the docket, Trump has said. But the preparation bears little resemblance to the painstaking allied consultations that preceded Ronald Reagan’s Cold War summits with Mikhail Gorbachev, former U.S. Ambassador to China Nicholas Burns told CNN.
“President Trump is throwing a lifeline to Vladimir Putin, who has been spurned for nearly five years because of his aggression in Ukraine,” Burns said. “He lavishes praise on Xi Jinping, which I think is directly contrary to what he should be saying about Xi Jinping, who’s an adversary of the United States.”
From my @FT colleagues, on the upcoming trilateral meeting in Shenzhen: Moscow has made no secret of its desire to create a “new, modern-day Yalta” to reflect its aims in Europe. But a person close to the Kremlin said China’s reluctance to take a hands-on role in the Ukraine…
In every metric but nuclear warheads, Russia is the inferior power of the three.
The pageantry extended beyond the summit hall. In Manila earlier in the trip, Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. sent a late-night Jollibee fried chicken delivery to Trump’s delegation, boasting the chain had surpassed KFC in U.S. popularity. “Oh wow, fantastic,” Trump replied, though it was unclear whether he ate any, The Business Times reported. Trump also reunited with Imelda Marcos, the 97-year-old former first lady.
Back in Shenzhen, the optics cut both ways. Xi gains a domestic propaganda victory: the Chinese leader presiding over a “strategic stability” dialogue that implicitly recognizes Beijing as an equal convener. Trump gains the spectacle of a peacemaker — a counter-narrative after midterm rebukes at home. Putin gains rehabilitation, seated at the top table after years of Western isolation.
Trade negotiators from both sides huddled on the banquet sidelines. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent was present, CNBC noted, though U.S. officials said last week Trump did not plan to raise allegations involving Jensen Huang and an alleged Chinese spy during the Xi meeting. Trump did, however, briefly raise the Nvidia matter, Sky News reported.
President Trump's trilateral summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin has the makings of an unpredictable spectacle – and that's exactly what has U. S. allies anxious. My story on @axios https://t.co/sDYY70NwCg
Trump claimed pending deals with various countries would eliminate tariffs on U.S. exports and benefit American farmers and energy, though he offered no specific terms, figures or timeline, The Business Times said.
The applause for Xi’s morning speech was muted; attendees raised smartphones instead of clapping. “The entire multilateral framework needs to change,” Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim declared, praising China’s “rare” recognition of smaller nations. By evening, Trump was not the one holding the microphone.
Ukraine and European capitals watch for understandings forged at their expense. So does the Middle East, where Iran’s nuclear program remains a flashpoint.
Personal chemistry between Trump and Xi could provide a crisis hotline — perhaps over a South China Sea confrontation — but it also emboldens Beijing if Washington later attempts pressure, Steve Tsang told CNN. “Xi won’t be rude because he wants to maintain a good relationship, whatever his personal feelings about Donald Trump.”
The trilateral meeting was still hours away as night fell on Shenzhen.
By meeting Donald Trump and Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin is sending a holiday postcard to the rest of the world. But instead of ‘Wish you were here’, he’s signed it ‘Look: I’m here.’ My report from Shenzhen. https://t.co/K3SfGT57fN
More on Shenzhen
President Donald Trump, Chinese leader Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin are expected to hold a three-way summit on the sidelines of this week’s APEC meeting in Shenzhen, China. “No U. S. president has ever held a trilateral meeting with the leaders of China and…”
Russia, China, US leaders to meet in Shenzhen on November 19 – Kremlin “An agreement has been reached to hold a trilateral meeting on the 19th between President Putin, President Xi, and President Trump. The meeting will take place in Shenzhen on the sidelines of the APEC… pic.twitter.com/BTkgI3YcTf”
Putin sees an opportunity in the Trump-Xi meeting | Russian President Vladimir Putin anticipates significant benefits from a trilateral meeting with US President Donald Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping. This meeting is set to occur on the sidelines of the APEC summit in… pic.twitter.com/Zc8poBlfNv
Donald Trump is arriving at an unprecedented summit meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin politically weakened at home, yet perhaps even more eager to flex his power abroad https://t.co/tDckZNxgum
Worth a look
- South Africa Passport Ranks 119th, Behind Somalia and Russia on GDP-Weighted Index
- Forensic Experts Claim Epstein Injuries Indicate Homicidal Strangulation, Not Suicide
- Trump's Beef Quota Filled About 37% in Month One; Ground Beef Fell 13 Cents (daybreakwire.com)
- Trump, Xi and Putin set for historic trilateral talks at APEC summit (newsarchyuk.com)