Pennsylvania’s newly elected Democratic trifecta in Harrisburg faces immediate pressure to regulate the rapid expansion of energy-intensive data centers. While the state’s November midterms shifted the legislative balance, it remains unclear whether lawmakers will prioritize aggressive new oversight or balance environmental concerns against the state’s existing economic development incentives when the session begins in January.
The pressure on Harrisburg
Data centers emerged as a flashpoint during the recent midterm elections, with candidates across the state debating the environmental and fiscal costs of these massive computing warehouses.
The prospect of a Democratic-controlled House, Senate, and Governor’s office has emboldened advocates who argue that the current pace of development is unsustainable.
Lauren Posey, an environmental policy advocate with Protect PT, emphasized that the urgency of the issue stems from the tangible impacts these facilities have on local communities.
“It’s still a very pressing and urgent subject that we need to address, especially as these facilities are — some of them are already being built, and they do stand to have a range of concerning impacts in terms of energy use and environmental and public health.”
Posey said.
Codifying grid standards
One potential avenue for reform involves the formal adoption of standards previously proposed by Governor Josh Shapiro. These proposed policies are designed to grant local areas greater influence over data center projects, establish parameters for power consumption, and mandate that developers cover the expenses associated with grid infrastructure integration.
Patrick McDonnell, CEO of PennFuture, said that while these standards represent a necessary starting point, they currently lack teeth because no developers have signed on to the program. He suggested that the election results provide a clear mandate for lawmakers to transform these voluntary benchmarks into law.
“I think these are all things that legislators know their constituents have an expectation that they’re going to deliver for constituents. And I think they’ll want to demonstrate that they had heard that message loud and clear.”
McDonnell said.
Revisiting stalled legislation
During the prior legislative period, the Democratic-led House approved various measures that would have mandated clean energy standards for data centers, eliminated tax breaks for computing hardware, and empowered local governments to pause data center projects in their regions. These measures all stalled in the Republican-controlled Senate, but the new legislative landscape may offer a second chance for these proposals.
David Hess, a former secretary for the state Department of Environmental Protection, tracks these issues through his PA Environment Digest blog.
He argues that the election results allow for a more nuanced approach than simply reintroducing old legislation.
“We can go back and rethink some of these bills in light of those results and say, can we do better? Can we do better bringing cheaper energy generation onto the grid than natural gas, which will take years,” Hess said.
He added that the legislature should focus on energy conservation, solar energy, and geothermal energy as alternatives to traditional power sources.

The affordability divide
While data centers are unpopular—with August polling from Franklin and Marshall College indicating that about 80% of Pennsylvania voters oppose having a facility in their community—the issue did not necessarily drive the election results in a partisan way. Berwood Yost, who directs the Center for Opinion Research at Franklin and Marshall College, said that the discussion around data centers was often filtered through broader concerns about the cost of living.
With 57% of recent poll respondents reporting they are having some trouble affording utility bills, the intersection of energy demand and consumer pricing has become a central concern.
Robert Routh, Pennsylvania policy director with the Natural Resources Defense Council, believes that protecting the environment and stabilizing electricity costs are linked. He advocates for a comprehensive regulatory framework that prevents developers from passing the costs of grid upgrades onto everyday residents.
“Those are the circumstances that lead me to believe there’s good reason to expect early action on it,” Routh said, while acknowledging that it is still early days for the incoming session.
The fiscal reality
Despite the push for regulation, lawmakers face a difficult balance regarding state revenue. Data center operators currently benefit from tax exemptions for computing equipment, which are expected to cost the state more than $188 million this fiscal year. Critics, including Matthew Mehalik, executive director of the Breathe Project, argue that this tax break functions as a “black hole” in the state budget, providing little in the way of permanent local employment in exchange for significant environmental degradation.
However, Yost cautioned that the narrow 26-24 majority Democrats will hold in the Senate could complicate efforts to repeal these incentives. Some legislators may be hesitant to turn away potential revenue, even if those funds come from industries that are currently out of favor with their constituents.
The legislature is expected to convene in January, at which point the path forward for data center policy will likely become clearer.