The homicide suspect arrested at Tempe Marketplace after 414 days had lived quietly in a Mesa home for months.
More than a year after an 18-year-old was shot dead in a Milwaukee alley, the suspect arrested at an Arizona shopping center had spent months living quietly in a Mesa home.
Damarius Montgomery, 19, was taken into custody at Tempe Marketplace on Nov. 13, FOX 10 Phoenix reported, capping a manhunt that stretched 1,700 miles from the scene of the crime. The U.S. Marshals Service announced the arrest Thursday, noting that Montgomery faces charges of first-degree reckless homicide and attempted armed robbery in the death of Bryan Jamison.
Prosecutors allege Jamison was lured into the alley on Sept. 26, 2025, under the pretense of robbing a drug dealer — a plan authorities say was actually a ruse to steal Jamison’s own firearm. He was shot that night and died later at a hospital.
“Bryan Jamison was 18 years old when he was killed,” said U.S. Marshal Van Bayless for the District of Arizona. “Our partners in Wisconsin developed the lead that brought this investigation to Arizona, and our task force acted on it. This arrest is a step toward getting answers for Bryan’s family and allowing the case to move forward in Milwaukee.”
The Eastern Wisconsin Violent Offender Task Force took over the investigation and traced Montgomery to Arizona, according to AZFamily. Wisconsin authorities then requested assistance from Arizona’s WANTED Violent Offender Task Force. On the day of the arrest, investigators first located Montgomery at a residence in Mesa before apprehending him hours later at the busy Tempe Marketplace retail center.

Montgomery was booked into Maricopa County Jail pending extradition to Wisconsin. The Marshals Service noted this was one of two fugitive arrests made by the Arizona task force within a two-day span; the previous day, a teen was arrested in Mesa in connection with a shooting in Connecticut.
Tempe Marketplace, the open-air center where Montgomery was arrested, sits on 130 acres along the Salt River near the Loop 101 and Loop 202 interchange. The land was once a landfill so contaminated it joined the U.S. E.P.A. Superfund List in 1983; it was removed 20 years later after what became the largest Brownfield cleanup in Arizona history. The center opened on September 28, 2007, after developers assembled the site from 52 individual lot owners.
The gap between the shooting and the arrest — 414 days — shows the reach of the federal task force model, but it also leaves a family waiting. Jamison’s relatives have not spoken publicly since the arrest was announced. Montgomery’s initial court appearance in Arizona has not yet been scheduled.